Reader's Rights

That’s Not How It Happened In the Movie!

No, that’s not a typo.  I know there is some debate about whether it is better to read the book or see the film adaptation first. a63a58cdd13b01b21b39997c9fcb215e Frankly, I don’t care.  I love movies just about as much as I love books.  I discover a lot of my reading material through movies.  Just check out my book lists on Goodreads.com; it is packed with books adapted into movies and plays.  On rare occasions, a book’s adaption will put me off reading a book I was on the fence about.  Not because the movie is necessarily bad but because it just didn’t interest me enough to read the book.

Like many readers, I enjoy the opportunity to use my imagination in picturing the characters and the settings based on the author’s descriptions and representations.  And like most, I am usually (but not always) disappointed in the movie if I’ve read the book first.  I often feel like I could have done a better job and kept all of the good bits in.  My worst experience with a film adaptation was that of Corelli’s Mandolin.  The novel is so wonderful and beautiful that I often skipped classes during college because I could not put it down.  So when I heard that it was being adapted, I absolutely had to go see it.  They cut out all of the best scenes and characters and changed the most moving moments completely.  So, you know, your typical film hack job.

8b3898b8c49d8121137284b99ebc6dee
Just looking at the picture makes me sad.

On the other hand, when I see the film first and like it (inspiring me to read the book), I typically enjoy both.  That certainly proved true of two of my most recent reads.

When I found out that The Princess Bride began life as a novel – written by William Goldman who also wrote the brilliant screenplay – I knew I had to read it.  But I was a little nervous going in.

Would I be disappointed?

 Would it ruin the movie for me? 

Could the book possibly be as funny as the hilarious and classic movie?

1c9c35e1c64e65a92ad4e88dcd4eefd6

NOT A CHANCE!

NO WAY!

AB-SO-LUTE-LY!!

For anyone out there who loves the film version of The Princess Bride – and I know there are a lot of you – I definitely recommend reading the novel.

6ac34468b3961c462490e4d522fe46a1

And so many of those quotable lines are in the book!

 

The characters you love (and love to hate!), that fabulously wicked sense of humor, and the edge-of-your-seat adventure.  It’s all there.  Only more so.  I think that’s what I love about finding out a movie I enjoyed is based on a book.  The book gives me more of the things I loved about the movie.  And it’s at its best when the movie manages to capture the overall tone of the book like The Princess Bride does.

Before reading The Princess Bride, I finally – after looking at it sitting on my shelf for years – read Seabiscuit:  An American Legend by Laura Hillenbrand.  I just loved the film version.  I mean, who doesn’t love a good underdog (or horse) story?  I think I thought the non-fiction book would be dry and dull like a textbook.  It was neither.  Though there were many more differences between the book and the movie than with The Princess Bride, they shared the most important qualities.  There is the connection of the Seabiscuit’s story to his historical era, the heart-stopping excitement of the race scenes, and the emotional connection to the characters, human and equine.

The book, though, also has a lot of information (I learned so much about the sport of horse racing, a subject I didn’t even know I wanted to learn about) and several major changes and omissions were made in adapting it for the film.  Does that mean that I like the movie any less?  No, not really.  What it means is that whenever I watch it from now on, I will be saying, “That’s not how it happened in the book!”

Advertisements
Biography/Memoir, Reviews

Review: Seabiscuit: An American Legend

Seabiscuit: An American Legend
Seabiscuit: An American Legend by Laura Hillenbrand

My rating: 5 of 5 stars

I typically stay away from non-fiction and I had no previous interest in horse racing so I probably wouldn’t have read Laura Hillenbrand’s fabulous Seabiscuit: An American Legend if I didn’t absolutely love the film version with its edge-of-your-seat action and subtle, intelligent humor. Those qualities came from the book. Even though I know (a version of) the story, I found myself tearing through the passages about the races with rapt attention as if I were sitting in the grandstand and laughing out at the wicked humor, especially that of Tom Smith. Most importantly, though, I learned so much about the sport, about the people that are a part of the sport, and the history of our country at a tumultuous period.
The first part of the book moves a bit slower than the rest of the book as Hillenbrand introduces the reader to a multitude of characters with an intimate focus on Charles Howard, Tom Smith, Red Pollard, George Woolf, and, of course, Seabiscuit. So at first, I was afraid that my preconception about non-fiction, that it is dull and minutely detailed, might be true of Seabiscuit: An American Legend. I am so glad that I was wrong.

View all my reviews