My rating: 3 of 5 stars
This first book in Genevieve Cogman’s steampunk fantasy series, The Invisible Library, brings to mind both Jasper Fforde’s Thursday Next series and Gail Carriger’s Parasol Protectorate series. Take a less confident and exciting Thursday and drop her in Carriger’s version of Victorian London and you have Irene, a Librarian on a mission.
Though it lacks the fun of Carriger’s novels and isn’t as well put together as Fforde’s, the concept of an all-encompassing library with agents recruited, trained, and sent out to alternate worlds to collect special, rare, or important books, has potential. The setting of Irene’s mission is wrought with dangers that include the Fae, Vampires, Werewolves, giant metal insects, and one fabled rogue Librarian. It is these dangers that give the story its thrills but I often found myself confused about the magic of Cogman’s creation. It seemed as though the rules of the Library (and the alternate) change to suit the story. I couldn’t get a hold of Irene’s character either – sometimes she’s modern while other times she’s old-fashioned like the setting of her mission; sometimes she’s a strict rule follower and sometimes she’s making things up as she goes. As for the other characters, I like Peregrin Vale very much because, like Irene, and a big Sherlock Holmes fan; I am looking forward to getting to the mysterious Kai better as I continue to read the series (because I will be continuing though I wasn’t sure I until the end of this book whether I would or not), but Bradamant I could have done without.
If you enjoy The Invisible Library because you are a bibliophile who dreams of living in a library or inside the books themselves, pick up Jasper Fforde’s Thursday Next Series beginning with The Eyre Affair. If it is the fantastical setting you like, and you wished this book had a bit of romance, I highly recommend Gail Carriger’s Parasol Protectorate, the first book of which is Soulless.